Journal of Other Forum Analysis (Volume II, Issue 1)

[benji]

Why do all these fuckers want to have autism? It literally makes no sense

Because it's about getting an Official Seal of Quality™ that says nobody is allowed to disagree with you.

https://www.resetera.com/threads/the-road-to-re-meducalization-of-trans-people-begin-as-all-kids-seeking-gender-care-will-be-screened-for-autsim-and-adhd-in-uk.1175145/#post-139187121

Even simply forcing trans children to 'rule out' other conditions before letting them access needed gender affirming care, when getting an autism screening involves a long wait is further intentional and cruel sabotage of positive outcomes.

This post just highlights to me how confused and shambolic trans rhetoric has become.

Here, Plagiarize writes a sentence around his asshole to his elbow to insinuate some vague but awful risk in this dynamic. He still wants to leverage urgency of the suddenly-shockingly-rare "...or they'll kill themselves!", but it's like new talking points went out in the past months that said "stop saying that, people are now realizing it sounds like a mental health issue   ".

But "trans me (now) or I'll kill myself" is the foundation of the entire modern trans rights platform. Like, if you take that plank out, then transition suddenly requires no special privileges or protections beyond what is already granted to any random on the street.

I would say that the foundation is that it's verboten to question anything asserted by self-identified members of the class. That the person has perfect knowledge that's superior to anyone else and therefore everyone has a duty to provide whatever they demand. Echos parroted the language perfectly, that it's an offense to say that the mentally ill don't have perfect understanding of everything and what they need above and beyond anyone including field experts and the entire field itself and maybe even the very concept of science as it's been known for effectively centuries.

The suicide threats are just because that's generally the primary way to short circuit any questioning and have the "issue" handed off to someone else. And all the mental health professionals would throw out their guidelines to insist that trans people are so special and unique that in their case such threats mean the patients are perfect and it's everyone else who needs to make changes. Or else they really will kill themselves, even though we don't have any data that shows trans people are more prone to this than anyone else with mental illnesses. In fact we don't even have data period because it's been verboten to collect any data on anything involving this subject. The entire field is completely upside down with no evidence for anything because the claims themselves are simply untestable as the movement has spent all its time ensuring that it's unfalsifiable so people are forced to accept self-identification instead of anything that could "gatekeep" the movement from what it wants.

Most people will give into emotional blackmail because they don't want to feel guilty if someone does kill themselves. So of course nobody was ever going to say "no, that's stupid and doesn't make any sense, you should get actual therapy." That's not what the person wants to hear so they're going to become difficult and maybe violent. And people are so fucking stupid that in order to be a good progressives they'll willingly spend time arguing that biology isn't real and that "feeling like a girl/boy" is a claim that not just makes sense but is empirically and unquestionably true simply by the fact that it's claimed by someone.

It's exactly like creationism/intelligent design in that there's not even a compromise position that's acceptable to the movement other than the elimination of the truth for what they'd prefer only be said in hopes that somehow makes it true or at least means they never have to hear otherwise. And the rhetoric they use with each other is about ensuring nobody backs down from the most radical and extreme uncompromising position no matter how completely insane it is, it's almost literally "don't ask questions, just consume" such as this example from the last page:


These absolutely are cult tactics.